George, the maintenance guy, just left. He checked the water temp and then the thermostat setting on the water heater and came to the same conclusion that I did. Something is wrong with the water heater. The thermostat setting is on 140°, but you can hold your hand under the running "hot" water and not have to pull it away. There is no way that the water temp is 140°.
So, George will have Roto-Rooter call me and set up a time to come see what's wrong with the water heater.